Baseball Mode

Product Reviews

Baseball Scorebook Showdown: Our Top 8 Picks

Written by Chris 

Published on February 22, 2024

In youth baseball, keeping a scorebook is often a job for a coach or a knowledgeable parent, even with popular apps like GameChanger available. There's something special about doing it by hand—a true old-school way of staying connected to the game. After evaluating various options, we’ve identified the best baseball scorebook that excels in usability, design, and overall quality.

Best Baseball Scorebooks

We’ve compiled a list of the top baseball scorebooks, each carefully selected for its features, durability, and positive feedback from users. Explore our recommendations to find the perfect scorebook that meets your needs.

1. Murray Sporting Goods Baseball Scorebook

The Murray Sporting Goods Baseball & Softball Scorebook is ideal for anyone needing to track team stats throughout a season. It’s suitable for various leagues, from youth to adult teams, with room to score 35 games. This scorebook covers all the essentials—batting, fielding, pitching stats, and more—across 9 innings.

 

A standout feature is its side-by-side layout, which lets you easily track 16-player rosters for both teams without flipping pages. The spiral-bound design ensures durability, and the included instructions make it user-friendly for all skill levels.

Murray Sporting 
Goods Scorebook

View Now

2. Score It Right Baseball Scorebook

The Score It Right Baseball Scorebook is a solid option for tracking team stats over 30 games. Made with high-quality paper, it features clear, precise lines for easy readability. Its advanced layout allows you to record scores, batting averages, season totals, and extra innings with ease.


With 16 lineup spots, you can monitor each player's performance, and it includes extra inning tear-outs for added convenience during extended games. This scorebook is designed to keep your scorekeeping organized and straightforward and would make a great gift for coaches.

Score It Right 
Baseball Scorebook

View Now

3. Rawlings Extra Large Deluxe Baseball Scorebook

This Rawlings SYSTEM-17 Scorebook is worth considering for its extra-large size and easy-to-learn scoring system. This scorebook should be the choice for those who need lots of space to record their team's scores and stats. Its extra-large 11" x 14" size provides more room for each batter and includes space for 9 innings, 17 players, and 2 substitutes per player.


Made for 24 games, the Rawlings Scorebook is built to last and is suitable for both baseball and softball. The spiral binding also ensures that the pages remain secure and can be easily turned during gameplay.

Rawlings XL 
Baseball Scorebook

View Now

4. C.S. Peterson's Scoremaster Baseball Scorebook

This is the book I remember my coaches always using. It has to be the "OG" of baseball scorebooks. The fact that it's still doing well after all these years should tell you something.


This scorebook offers an easy and organized way to keep track of individual players' batting records and pitching performance during games. Its comprehensive design provides all the necessary details for both official scorers and casual fans.

5. CHAMPRO Baseball Scorebook

The CHAMPRO Baseball Scorebook is a versatile and user-friendly option for coaches and scorekeepers. Its well-organized layout simplifies managing team and player stats, while the heavy-duty cardstock backing ensures it lasts all season.


A key feature is its capacity to accommodate up to 18 players per team, providing ample space for recording substitutions and player performance, which is ideal for youth leagues and larger rosters.


Additionally, it includes scoring instructions and lineup cards, making it a great choice for those new to scorekeeping.

6. Franklin Sports Baseball Scorebook

The Franklin Sports Baseball Scorebook is the perfect choice for those seeking a straightforward and easy-to-use book for tracking games and stats.


It features an uncomplicated design, making it perfect for both beginners and experienced scorekeepers. One of the advantages of this 25 game scorebook is the presence of easy-to-follow instructions, helping newcomers to baseball scoring get started quickly. The format of the score sheets makes it super simple to score games.


There's a lineup section that accommodates up to 16 players, allowing you to manage not only the starting lineup but also the bench players and any extra hitters. Additionally, a team roster page is included for recording player information and crucial contact details.

7. Markwort Baseball Scorebook

The Markwort Baseball & Softball Scorebook allows you to keep track of games and player statistics easily, with enough room to record up to 23 games per book. This scorebook is designed to provide information on seasonal data, as well as individual batting and fielding results. With space for up to 15 players and 11 innings on each page, this scorebook gets the job done.

8. Covey Baseball Scorebook

The Covey Baseball Softball Scorebook offers a practical, easy-to-use design with a side-by-side format allowing scorekeepers to track both teams on the same page for up to 50 games. This scorebook is compact and convenient for storage or transport, measuring 15 x 11 inches, but still provides enough space for both teams' stats. This versatility makes it a great choice for baseball, fastpitch softball, or slowpitch softball coaches and fans.


Another great feature of the Covey Baseball Softball Scorebook is its functional scoring sheets. They include a pitch count tracker for five pitchers per team and space for 12 players in the batting order.

Buying Guide

When choosing a baseball scorebook, consider these key features:

Durability: Opt for sturdy materials, like wire bindings and weather-resistant paper, to ensure longevity.

Size and Layout: Choose a portable scorebook with ample space for clear writing. Common sizes include 8.5"x11" and 9"x12".

Game Capacity: Select one that fits your season, ranging from 25 to 100 games.

Features: Look for pre-printed lineup cards, a pitch tracker for monitoring pitch counts, and sections for statistical summaries to aid post-game analysis.

We hope this buying guide helps you find the perfect baseball scorebook that meets your requirements and enhances your scorekeeping experience. Good luck with your search!

How to Score a Baseball Game

Scoring a baseball game requires detailed attention and knowledge of the rules. We'll guide you through the process step by step. First, understanding the symbols and abbreviations is crucial as it makes it easy to keep track of the game.

Common Scoring Abbreviations:

1B: Single (one base hit)

2B: Double (two base hit)

3B: Triple (three base hit)

HR: Home Run

BB: Base on balls (Walk)

HBP: Hit by pitch

K: Strikeout

E: Error

F(number) - flied out to position

F.O. (number) - fouled out to (position)

F.C. - fielder's choice

IF - infield fly called

StB - stolen base

Reversed K - struck out looking

C.S. - caught stealing

S.B. - sacrifice bunt

S.F. - sacrifice fly

To start, each square on the scorecard represents a player's at-bat. Write the player's number in the top left and their position in the top right. As the game progresses, use symbols and lines to track plays. For example, mark a single with "1B" and a line to first base. If a player reaches second on an error, write "E" with the fielder’s number and draw the line to second.


Track runs by outlining and filling the base path from third to home. Keep a running tally in the score section.


For pitching, record each pitch and track balls, strikes, and outs. Regularly update the pitcher's stats, including innings, hits, runs, walks, strikeouts, and earned runs.

Tips for Accuracy:

Review the lineup before the game.

Keep extra pencils and erasers handy.

Cross-check your scorecard with the scoreboard.

Scoring enhances your understanding of the game and gets easier with practice.

Baseball Scorebook Rankings - Final Thoughts

We've explored the top 8 picks and even learned how to manually score a game. Remember, keeping a scorebook isn't just about jotting down numbers; it's about creating your own fun connection to the game. Whether you're a coach, a casual fan, a parent, or a player, using a scorebook can truly enhance your baseball experience. Here's to the timeless joy of baseball and the simple pleasure of keeping score!